Our Best Ice Cube Tray Recommendations

Every fridge must have a functional ice cube tray. Ice cube trays are in fact, quite versatile since they are not only used to freeze water for ice cubes—it also functions as a container to freeze various foods from baby food puree, excess pesto or tomato paste, for freezing leftover stocks, making popsicles and more. For those in the market for quality ice cube trays, we would love to help you in this search—check out our handy guide for the best ice cube trays in the business today.

Buyers Guide

  1. What materials are ice cube trays made of?

    Answer: Ice cube trays today are not only made from metal, but they are also available in plastic and silicone forms. Plastic ice cube trays are the most affordable options but this material often has a tendency to take in odors from the freezer then transmit said smells to the ice cubes. Silicone makes extracting ice cubes easier but like plastic material, also absorbs odors coming from the freezer. Thus far, metal ice cube trays are considered to be the best material to contain ice cubes due to the material’s durability.

  2. How can you minimize odors and taste from plastic and silicone ice cube trays?

    Answer: To prevent odor risks, you can pop the ice cubes out of the tray and choose to store them in an airtight container. Defrosting and cleaning the freezer frequently will also help in preventing odors from accumulating in the area. You can also remove odors from plastic and silicone ice cube trays by immersing the items in a baking soda solution. A soak using a mixture of lemon juice and water/vinegar and water blend can also help take away odors.

  3. What factors should I consider when choosing ice cube trays?

    Answer: Check the material that the ice cube tray is made of. As mentioned previously, ice cube trays are either made with plastic, metal or silicone materials. Quality ones are usually made from BPA-free, food-grade, non-toxic materials. Choose an ice cube tray bearing a size that you prefer—ice cube trays these days are available in several sizes to accommodate various needs. Assess the capacity and number of trays you require—the ice cube tray should feature the number of slots that fit your needs.

Our Top Picks


Onyx 18/8 Stainless Steel # ICE001 Ice Cube Tray

  • Quality, safe 18/8 stainless steel
  • Classic two-part system
  • Has easy-release handle
  • BPA/toxin-free

These stainless steel ice cube trays from Onyx are one to trust—it is made from quality 18/8 stainless steel that’s free from harmful toxins and BPA elements. The trays feature a stackable design for easier organization. Because it’s made from stainless steel, these trays will last many uses, extra-sturdy enough to withstand freezing temps every day. To make ice removal effortless, this one comes with an easy-release handle. The tray also features a classic 2-part system design which goes back to old-fashioned trays from the 50s. Stainless steel also helps in preventing odor buildup so your cubes stay fresh and taste-free as they should be.


Tovolo Perfect Ice Mold Freezer Tray

  • Creates 1.25-inch ice cubes
  • Food-grade silicone material
  • Multipurpose tray
  • Dishwasher-safe

The Tovolo Perfect Ice Mold Freezer Tray was designed to churn out 1.25-inch cubes and accommodate various purposes. It’s not only a quality tray for making ice cubes; you can also freeze leftover food items in them like baby food, stocks, soups, sauces, juices and more. The tray is made with safe, food-grade silicone which will not add any unnecessary taste or odor on your ice cubes. The tray is completely free from nasties like phthalates, BPA and PVC plus they are a snap to maintain—it’s dishwasher-safe for minimal maintenance.


OMorc Ice Cube Trays (4-Pack)

  • Food-grade silicone and PP materials
  • LFGB-certified BPA-free
  • Simple ice removal
  • Stackable and removable lid

These OMorc Ice Cube Trays comes as a set of 4 trays and you can make enough ice on these items for parties and get-togethers. Every tray in the set can contain up to 14 cubes. The trays all have a removable and stackable lid to prevent odor buildup and spills. It is made from food-grade, BPA-free flexible silicone material so ice cube removal is always done in a snap—you only need to press every compartment separately to take away the precise number of ice cubes you want. Due to the included lids, they make for better organization in the freezer too—they help save space due to their stackable design.


Glacio Ice Cube Trays

  • Creates 6 sizable ice cubes
  • Great for chilling cocktail glasses
  • Round ice ball molds
  • Non-stick design

If you want variety in your ice cubes, then the Glacio Ice Cube Trays should be your top pick. Apart from regular cube-shaped ice, this set also includes a tray for rounded ice—the ice balls add visual pep to any cocktail glass. Due to the size, these ice cube and balls also help in keeping your glass chilled to perfection. The tray is made with food-grade silicone that’s 100% safe and free from BPA elements. Because it’s silicone-made, this item is quite flexible and removal of each ice ball/cube is made simpler. It’s dishwasher-safe and ideal for freezing baby food, soups and fruit juices too.


Lekue Ice Box Silicone Ice Cube Tray

  • BPA-free ABS plastic
  • Includes hollow base to prevent condensation
  • Strong silicone lid
  • Store up to 132 ice cubes

The Lekue Ice Box Silicone Ice Cube Tray is your ideal party ice cube maker since it can contain up to 132 cubes. That’s enough to keep your get-togethers going. To keep things chilled and perfect, the trays are made with a hollow base to stop condensation and it’s also fashioned with an air chamber for better thermal insulation. To avoid odor buildup, the trays feature an insulated built and silicone lids. Made to last and promote safety, the trays are made with BPA-free ABS plastic.


OXO Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack)

  • Set has 2 trays
  • Includes covers
  • Spherical ice shape
  • Dishwasher-safe

The Good Grips Covered Ice Cube Tray from OXO is another great pick—made from PFOA/BPA/phthalate-free material. It has covers which allow the trays to be stored in a stacked manner. The lids are also helpful in odor control. Instead of giving a cubed shape for the ice, the ice are formed into balls for easier tray removal. For maintenance, these trays are a breeze to clean since they are dishwasher safe.

Do not overlook the quality of your ice cube tray. Make sure that they are durable, safe and prevent odors from forming on your ‘cubes. Quality ones will also help you save money on these items in the long run. Check out our list for excellent finds that are worthy of your attention and purchase.