Our Favorite Ice Cream Makers to Date

Thanks to today’s innovative kitchen technologies, we can now create our very own gallon of ice cream in the comfort of our own homes. Whether you pursue an original creation or just opt for ice cream recipes made available online, homemade ice cream is made even better with a trusty ice cream maker. In the market for an efficient ice cream maker to use at home? Let our list of the best ice cream makers in the industry today help in your decision.

Buyers Guide

  1. What are the different types of ice cream makers?

    Answer: There are 3 common kinds of ice cream makers—the rock salt and ice method, the freezer bowl and the compressor unit. The rock and salt ice method is a traditional way of whipping up the frozen concoction. It is composed of 2 containers with room in-between the two containers where the ice and salt are contained. This method also involves manually churning the ice cream ingredients. The freezer bowl method engages the use of a specific liquid between bow layers which brings the ice cream ingredients to an appropriate temperature. The system is composed of the freezer bowl and a paddle. The compressor unit meanwhile makes the whole process of making ice cream and effortless one. This device brings the temperature of the ice cream ingredients below freezing temps rapidly so there’s no need for additional preparation needed.

  2. What capacities are available for ice cream makers?

    Answer: Small ice cream makes can contain less than a quart of ice cream so it’s ideal for single servings. Medium ones can accommodate 1 to 2 quarts of ice cream and it’s ideal for serving 1-2 individuals. Large ones are made to churn out bigger amounts of ice cream and can accommodate 2 to 4 quarts of ice cream. These units though can take a bit of time to fully create ice cream.

  3. What should I look for in ice cream makers?

    Answer: First, you need to determine if your freezer can accommodate an ice cream maker with a freezer bowl. Compressor units are designed to tackle bigger batches of ice cream but are often a bit bigger so they require more room. In addition, you need to consider the method in which you want to create ice cream—electric models make things easier while manual ones will take a good amount of time and effort. Next, do not forget to consider how many servings you want out of the machine—if you are planning to serve several people at once, you do have to consider a large-capacity ice cream maker.

Our Top Picks

#1

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

  • Creates 2 quarts ice cream
  • Includes enhanced paddle
  • Has countdown timer
  • Features automatic shutoff

The Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker is a versatile model that not only churns out ice cream, it can also be used to produce your favorite sorbet, gelato and yogurt flavors. This is a versatile and reliable compressor-type ice cream maker that offers automatic shutoff, several speeds and provides up to 2 quarts of ice cream or any frozen concoction. This is a one-touch operation device which makes it a user-friendly option. The lid of this unit is clear so you can check the progress of your ice cream & mixture. Already comes with a built-in measuring cup.

#2

Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker

  • Has stainless steel housing
  • Include built-in audible timer
  • BPA-free aluminum material
  • Award-winning design

The efficacy of the Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker has been recognized by the Wirecutter website and Real Simple magazine. The device is equipped with a durable, powerful compressor freezer which won’t require users to pre-freeze ice cream ingredients. The ice cream maker will stop motor operations automatically as soon as the mixture hardens for better ice cream quality. This one is easy to operate and clean—it has a churning blade for ease of serving ice cream and storage plus its stainless steel exteriors make for fuss-free cleanups too.

#3

Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker

  • Creates 4 quarts of ice cream
  • Has transparent lid
  • Includes carrying handle
  • Features electric motor

The Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE ice cream maker creates a visual impact in any kitchen—its whimsical retro appearance will inspire you to create loads of delicious, fun ice cream flavors to serve friends and family. The set-up even involves the old-timey use of ice to freeze the ice cream ingredients. The churning mechanism though is still electric so there’s no need to double your effort. The unit also includes a plastic bucket which functions as a storage container as well when used along with the lid. It has a handle for fast transportation. The motor of this device also locks in place when the machine is turned off.

#4

Chef’n Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker

  • Easy to use
  • Includes scoop and spade
  • Multi-functional device
  • Hand-washable

The Chef’n Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker makes the production of frozen treats an effortless pursuit. Users only need to freeze the dish in advance, put all ice creams ingredients and the procedure will begin automatically. Next, users have to scoop and churn the mixture for a few minutes till they achieved their preferred texture and consistency. This model only stands less than 3 inches tall so storage is not that much of a problem for this one. It’s a manual model so you’ll save up on electricity use and the whole package already comes with a blade, scoop and even a book of recipes.

#5

Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker

  • Completely automatic mode
  • Has Easy-Lock lid
  • Provides 4-quart capacity
  • Includes more than 20 ice cream recipes

The Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker is another multi-purpose model that’s great to use not only on ice cream recipes but sorbets, gelatos and frozen yogurt too. It has a 4-quart capacity, includes a seam-free aluminum bowl, an Easy-Lock lid and lots of recipes that you can practice on and enjoy. For simpler cleanups, this one has an aluminum canister. The device is fully automatic thus there’s no need for additional prep or steps—just sit back and let the unit work.

#6

White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Maker

  • Produces up to 6-quart ice cream
  • Triple-motion action dasher system
  • 12,000 RPM universal electric motor
  • Has stainless steel canister

One of the highlights of the White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Maker is its handcrafted New England pine wood bucket. This bucket is bordered by sturdy, galvanized hoops for the best durability. The whole ensemble also makes for a striking way to create ice cream. For the smoothest homemade ice cream, this one is equipped with a powerful 12,000 RPM electric motor that has a triple-motion action dasher system to achieve such silky, appetizing textures. It can produce 6 quarts of ice cream in a matter of 20-40 minutes too.

Create your own flavor ice cream at home with the help of a reliable ice cream maker. Whether you want something sweet or test out oddly-satisfying savory mixes, the structure and the handiness of an ice cream maker will make the process simpler and fast.